Grandstream GXP and GRP Phones going Offline Daily

Status
Not open for further replies.

bcarrico

Platinum Partner
Advanced Certified
Joined
Dec 18, 2019
Messages
43
Reaction score
27
We have started checking "online" extensions first thing in the morning through the 3CX Management Interface because we have to reboot Grandstream phones so much. They just show go offline. A reboot of the phone fixes the issue every time. We even have the client "factory reset" their phones when they notice it. It has become a real pain. Is this something known between 3CX and Grandstream? Or could it be something on my end? The configuration is mixed between SBC's and VPN. We have very few Direct SIP units. I don't have any of these issues with other phone manufactures.
 
Hi everybody,

just received a mail from grandstream that they released a Beta version 1.0.00.10 with the following bug fixes :
• Fixed Device freezes after disconnecting switch uplink
Fixed Devices randomly freezes
• Fixed Device only displays the first number when a LDAP Contact is set with multiple numbers

Could that be the solution because it is not clear what they say with 'FREEZES'.

Regards
Hans
 
Same issues here. Phones going offline randomly after a few days.
 
I am having the same problems as well. Multiple sites. All have Pi SBC. Software is 16.0.5.611. Using default 3CX Templates. Been following to see if there is a fix yet.
 
No SBC here, just the phones connected to the LAN.
 
Neither here, all on local lan and no changements in the lan.
Only installed updates for 3cx and the gxp phones.
Had last week another client, already up for 3 years, complaining about the same problem.

Bye
Hans
 
Bump

Me 3!!! Having same exact issue!

This is our first 3CX deployment and we decided to go with the GXP2170. We are new to VOIP and this is a major VIP customer. I had a feeling it was bunk firmware. But the boss and customer are gonna blame 3CX and my judgement.

How do I revert to the 10.0.9 firmware? I believe thats the firmware that the GXP's were shipped with but 3CX would not let me provision the phones until I updated. What should I do?
 
Hi everybody,

just received a mail from grandstream that they released a Beta version 1.0.00.10 with the following bug fixes :
• Fixed Device freezes after disconnecting switch uplink
Fixed Devices randomly freezes
• Fixed Device only displays the first number when a LDAP Contact is set with multiple numbers

Could that be the solution because it is not clear what they say with 'FREEZES'.

Regards
Hans

Have you tried the new firmware yet? Outside of 3CX not "officially" supporting it, did it work?
 
hi,

we have also applied, on different sites, a templates with the modified settings for P52 and P2397 as described before and it looks to be stable.

Bye
Hans
 
  • Like
Reactions: TDJ211
My systems have been stable with the latest handset firmware, system software and SBC's.

Oh so you ditched the custom templated P-code change and just went with the 1.0.11.10 firmware? All is good now?
 
Hi Marc,

i am still with firmware 1.0.11.6 but changed the template from 3cx with the following values as mentionned by 'Telephonics' in a previous replie with number #48 :

P52=2
P2397=1

Remark, i always change the original 3xc template file. When 3cx grant/release a new template it is much easier to reprovision all phones.

Bye
Hans
 
We have this same issue since January 2020. We have upgraded the 3cx server to the latest version and upgraded Grandstream GXP2130 phone firmware to the latest, 1.0.11.6. Then client keeps on complaining about phone disconnection since January. I did change the template to P52=2 and P2397=1 for the Grandstream phone and provision and reboot. But when I check the following day the phones still keep on disconnecting. Then I decided to downgrade to the working firmware before we upgraded to the latest firmware. So now all the phones are on firmware 1.0.9.102 and phones never disconnected and customer happy.
 
I went ahead and upgraded to the 1.0.11.10 firmware and it solved this particular issue. I noticed that this firmware has yet to be approved by 3CX but did notice that they pushed some GXP template updates recently.

Were those template updates related to this particular issue?

Im having another issue where 2 particular phones will intermittently not answer an incoming call from a ring group of 8 phones (once its determined phone will not answer, any other phone answers calls 100% of time).

Im wondering if it may be the reason why 3CX hasnt approved that newer firmware yet.
 
Last edited:
The template update appears to only be minor changes to timezone, dial plan and blind transfers. Not sure that would do anything to correct the problem with unregistering. The new firmware 1.0.11.10 is not approved by 3CX yet, so the phone reverts to 1.0.11.6 the next time it reprovisions.

I can upgrade the firmware and then keep the phone from reprovisioning, but before I do that, are you sure this new firmware upgrade fixes the problem with random unregistering?
 
Yes, I can confirm that it definitely does fix the lost registration issue.

But I started having an issue where the phones would intermittently not answer an incoming call from a ring group (all other phones would continue to ring like the handset was never picked up). I tried EVERYTHING I could possibly think of: replacing SBC, moved from SBC to direct SIP, numerous tweaks to networking/3CX, replaced switch, ethernet cables, ect

And after doing a plethora of research on these phones and reading the constant complaints of bad firmware (going back to 2018). I even found my exact issue that was eventually fixed by a firmware update.
https://www.3cx.com/community/threads/phones-cant-answer-calls-from-ring-groups-sometimes.63641/

So why the hell is it happening again?

So I replaced one of the Grandstreams with a Yealink T29G cuz the customer had just had it with this intermittent issue. And guess what? ALL problems disappeared. Call quality and delay drastically improved.

Even when the Grandstream would answer, there was always a 2 second delay from when you got the phone to your ear to when you could talk. So you had to delay your "Hello this is xyz company"

When I installed the Yealink, it worked like a phone is supposed work: answers incoming calls 100% of the time, no delay during the answer, no delay while talking. The customer said he didnt even bring up delay because he thought that was just was the deal with IP phones.

Well im here to say that its just the deal with these Grandstreams. And the deal is they are HOT GARBAGE. If I cant resell them Ill be more than happy to just throw them in the trash. I may even do just that to make myself feel better as opposed to passing on the problems to someone else.

I know replacing the phones is expensive, but when I factored in all the time Ive spent chasing all these little problems here and there and on top of it all sacrificing my reputation with this client, its worth every penny.
 
Last edited:
Does anybody have a copy of the bin file to version 1.0.9.135 so I can downgrade my 2170's while I wait for the newest version to work properly? I am currently spending my life babysitting my client's phone systems, rebooting their phones when I see one unregister. A huge waste of my time...
 
I have connected them through an SBC and not through an SBC. Doesnt matter. Still get random unregistering...

Unfortunately, I don't have the funds to replace all my client's phones, so I'm stuck trying to resolve this issue until 3CX or Grandstream figures it out.
 
I have connected them through an SBC and not through an SBC. Doesnt matter. Still get random unregistering...

Unfortunately, I don't have the funds to replace all my client's phones, so I'm stuck trying to resolve this issue until 3CX or Grandstream figures it out.
That's odd because a customer of mine is using the GRP2615 for executives and GXP2170 for employees. 2 SBC on-site (in HA cluster).

No issues at all.

Could it be network capacity? What's the hardware there?
 
I have 100 x 2170 out there with none of these issues now. What switches are they connected to? They're not some green energy saving units that switch port off?
What switches?

What router?

What ISP?

What's the internet speed? And how many phones?
 
Anybody have any updates to this? I am getting this same situation with some GRP2613s now as well.
 
Is anyone having any success with changing the p codes:
P52=2
P2397=1
Besides downgrading the firmware to 1.0.9.102?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Forum statistics

Threads
111,954
Messages
589,923
Members
164,852
Latest member
priya