MacOs Desktop App Menu Bar Icon

Status
Not open for further replies.

spuky

SOHO User
Basic Certified
Joined
Dec 17, 2019
Messages
22
Reaction score
21
I know there is another thread with the same title but that one is closed.... and marked as Solved...

The new Mac desktop App feels really off... here a screenshot off my Menubar

Bildschirmfoto 2022-07-18 um 21.50.22.png

you can tel every icon is BW (some of the apps provide colored Icons... but every app is configurable to a BW icon and none has Text. Next to the icon.

in the closed thread there is the following screenshot:

1647446293005.png

If you want to make your app stand out do it by features. Please tell your R&D Department to take an example from all other Mac Apps...

And don't let them tell you this Task is hard having used Electron myself... this should not take to long to make a Dropdown to select BW or Color Icon and a Checkbox to Remove Text. And if you are on it let them add another Checkbox to hide the dock Icon.

Don't get me wrong but this is taking up way to much space in the menu bar...in relation to the Amount of Information it provides... would like to be able to get more Information on a glance... If you want to take up that much space Id like to see things like number of voicemails / missed calls / current status... but the only information I get is... The App was started. that information is duplicated... because there is also no option to hide the Dock Icon... I want a status bar icon to be as minimal and as informativ as possible. That is the way to stand out... Not makeing your statusbar Icon an advert for a product i already own.

And I know your app is multiplatform but i guess windows users wouldn't say no to a more Informativ statusbar icon...

Would have loved to Post that under Ideas to get Votes from other mac users... but don't have permission to post Ideas. Maybe somebody could open a thread there would get my instant upvote...
 
And after having an glance at https://www.electronjs.org/docs/latest/api/tray I come to the conclusion that since

tray.setTitle(title[, options])
is a Mac os only Electron API some body put it there on purpose...
And it would be usefull to use it... if there are events... for example it would only apere if there is an incoming call (show the caller id) or if there where missed calls since the main app was last in the foregound..

But just setting the Title to the App name makes no sense... (just because an API exists you don't have to use it..).
 
I couldn't agree more, consumes so much room on the taskbar, simple fix.
 
Yes please Fix
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Forum statistics

Threads
112,025
Messages
590,367
Members
164,976
Latest member
Roman Mazur