Multiple router phones or just one?

Status
Not open for further replies.

qbitnetworking

Bronze Partner
Joined
Nov 28, 2020
Messages
138
Reaction score
30
Hi all, I'm deploying my first router phone setup and curious how best to do this. This is for a small office of about 7 users and the phones are all Yealink T53. Wondering if I should I set up each phone to be it's own SBC/router or should I pick one of them to be the SBC/router and provision the rest off of that one?

Thanks,
Jeremy
 
Works either way. If you have them be their own SBC then the phone is portable (can be taken home/off-site). If they share then the phone needs to be left on (mostly an issue when moving the person to a new office/cubicle).
 
  • Like
Reactions: qbitnetworking
Works either way. If you have them be their own SBC then the phone is portable (can be taken home/off-site). If they share then the phone needs to be left on (mostly an issue when moving the person to a new office/cubicle).
No noticeable performance differences? The only thing I can see being an issue with only one phone being the SBC is that user (most likely the receptionist) accidentally unplugging his/her phone and taking down every one else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: EmmettsIT
No noticeable performance differences? The only thing I can see being an issue with only one phone being the SBC is that user (most likely the receptionist) accidentally unplugging his/her phone and taking down every one else.
I haven't had occasion to set one up yet actually. They are limited to 10 phones using the SBC and/so are inherently limited by the phone's CPU. The advantage is using a phone is less expensive than setting up a Pi or VM or appliance. The disadvantage is it puts the phone near a person who may unplug it. If it was only a handful of phones I think I'd set them up on their own. If it was a lot, then an SBC. The question is what should be done in the middle and how likely is that particular phone to be unplugged? :)
 
I haven't had occasion to set one up yet actually. They are limited to 10 phones using the SBC and/so are inherently limited by the phone's CPU. The advantage is using a phone is less expensive than setting up a Pi or VM or appliance. The disadvantage is it puts the phone near a person who may unplug it. If it was only a handful of phones I think I'd set them up on their own. If it was a lot, then an SBC. The question is what should be done in the middle and how likely is that particular phone to be unplugged? :)
Limited to 10 phones if the other phones are not acting as their own router/SBC you mean, right? If all phones going in are router phones, then I just need to find out if there is any disadvantage to setting each one up as an SBC. There is clearly an advantage to doing so.
 
Right, 10 phones per router phone.
 
@JohnS_3CX can you give me your input on this one?
 
You can run each one as an individual router phone and they will be even more resilient since they don't all rely on one device.

The only con I see here is that local calls (between handsets and when no recording is enabled) will go out to the cloud and back. You end up using a little more bandwidth this way and introducing a bit of extra latency, but with under 10 phones it is probably not even noteworthy and you won't even notice it unless someone points it out.

Just make sure they all use wired ethernet since we do not support WiFi on any IP phones ;)
 
You can run each one as an individual router phone and they will be even more resilient since they don't all rely on one device.

The only con I see here is that local calls (between handsets and when no recording is enabled) will go out to the cloud and back. You end up using a little more bandwidth this way and introducing a bit of extra latency, but with under 10 phones it is probably not even noteworthy and you won't even notice it unless someone points it out.

Just make sure they all use wired ethernet since we do not support WiFi on any IP phones ;)
Oh shoot there is one phone in this install that needs to be on WiFi. I’ve run the Yealink WiFi dongles on the T43Us and have used the built in WiFi on a Yealink conference phone without issue (yet). Is this really that big of an problem?
 
@qbitnetworking From other posts I've seen here, it is unsupported in that if you have issues and ask for support they'll want you to plug it in. Also I want to say I've seen posts that the "router phone" setup didn't work on wireless, but it worked afterwards if you plug it in while setting up the router phone part. And of course overall, wireless can be unstable at times.
 
  • Like
Reactions: qbitnetworking
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members Online Now

Forum statistics

Threads
111,832
Messages
589,285
Members
164,662
Latest member
DejanMDS